massage and bodywork professionals
a community of practitioners
Tags:
Views: 4292
Daniel,
What you described seems to be the same in Mass and RI. The Asian places have establishment licenses but the "therapists" have no licenses (which is illegal) and they have no training. They are given a quick demo about how to "massage". They receive no pay (also illegal) and get only tips. The client is typically charged about $80 for the massage, that money goes to the establishment. Then after the massage, the client is pressured by both the "therapist" and the owner that they must tip at least $30 because otherwise the "therapist" does not get paid. So clients get a short session that is not really a massage... more like a quick "rub and tug." They pay too much money and leave with a negative impression of what therapeutic massage really is. Sadly, this system is bad for the so called therapists and bad for the massage industry as a whole. I wish they would just legalized prostitution and call it what it is. Truth in advertising and a separation between these places and those of us doing legitimate therapeutic bodywork.
... Depending on how much "service" they are willing to do they will wire between 7-20,000/month on tips only. You can do the math to see how much taxes are lost....
I do like the Chinese massage style and Korean acupressure but advertising for massage should be professional and not a sexual come on. As for truth in advertising the Chinese women the ads mention are usually not young and not trained in massage until they get here by a coach. They come to work a high pay cash job so they can support parents or children back in China. There are an estimated 30,000 women in the San Gabriel/Rosemead area that have come to do this and are ferried back and forth among the boss' parlors which may be in several states. They rent a bed where they leave their things and rest on the 4 days off/month for $200/month and have only minimal food expenses. All the rest is wired back to China (we have great control of illegal wire transfer following 9/11 don't we?) Depending on how much "service" they are willing to do they will wire between 7-20,000/month on tips only. You can do the math to see how much taxes are lost. The bosses make much more and often have 4 or 5 parlors. When they have taken care of family debts, set up husband or family member in their own business back home, bought the family a home, and saved enough to have no worries for a year, they go home to enjoy it. They have become a modern Mulan, family hero. The bosses are often heroes back home for entire towns where they provided economic success. This at the expense of the image of massage, particularly Asian American Therapists who have trouble finding legit employment and the American people who have been fleeced by a multi-billion dollar industry. While many immigrant populations send money back to family back home there is nothing to equal what the Chinese are doing here.
Much more going on here besides deceptive advertising.
Mike G said:
I think sometimes they imply some services are offered (ie. Magic Touch) when in reality they are not. It's more a marketing thing to get people through the door. Kinda along the lines the commercial where 50 women are chasing a guy down the street because he's wearing a certain brand cologne.
Marissa said:
It would be unfair to assume that if it was an Asian Massage Parlor that it's illicit. So too if it were Russian, Hispanic, Indian, or White take your pick. In this instance, I didn't know it was Asian until I saw the ads of little Asian girls in lingerie stating 'young Asian girls with magic touch'. Kind of hard to assume anything other than what they want you to at that point.
There are a host of such websites where seedy clients tell it all. I found this out a while ago when I was 'investigating' a business near me. There is this AMP less than two blocks away from my massage studio. When I first opened up my place was confused a few times with the MP and believe me I was not at all happy about it. I did some research online and in less than five minutes found several sites where the MP was listed by 'clientele' who discussed in detail the sexual services they received at the place! I anonymously shared the information with the state and local authorities but to date nothing has been done and it's been over two years. The MP is open all hours of the day and night (the Open sign never gets turned off! I've driven by at 1am and it's still on). I suspect authorities in town know what's going on but unfortunately no one seems to be bothered by it except for me :-(
Daniel, you are correct. MA does not require a license for some types of massage. As I understand it, they may not use the word "massage" anywhere in the signage or advertising. As for the business license, I do not know. But I do know that the state is new to regulating massage and they only have two people working in that department. They are completely overwhelmed with just dealing with licenses and renewals. I get the impression they have no time to check up on compliance issues.
I saw one place that advertises for and hires unlicensed people and students. They do it blatently and when anyone asks, they simply tell them "those therapists only do oriental work or foot reflexology." However the unlicensed people are doing full body swedish massages.
I think if the state hired just one more employee, and that person simply went from place to place, checking licenses and seeing first hand what goes on, they could more than make his salary in fines.
Lori there are two within a half mile of my place but I am only 20 minutes from San Gabriel where you find 1 or 2 on every block. They are the one hour foot massage places. But for 10 extra dollars and often no extra charge you get a full body massage. Some places have 15 stations working. Because it was feet they use to get a beauty salon permit for estheticians then do full body. Some cities realized what it was and require massage permits. I don't mind if it is a level playing field but how do you compete if they skirt the regulations, get paid only tips (already ruled illegal in courts) and live 4 to a room. We should make sure that each place is following the law for at least reasonable competition.
Perhaps we need to request a policy statement from CAMTC. The police are now only interested in those they can fine. In L.A. they have been going into Korean Massage businesses with guns out harassing them to make sure they are local licensed. Since CAMTC is not recognizing transcripts from Korean or Chinese massage schools they are forced to work where they can get local licenses still. Why the police do not go to the foot massage places I don't know. We really need some answers and since CAMTC is the state recognized entity over massage in California maybe it is time to clarify. The current law that authorizes the CAMTC expires in 2016. They need to be working for our support if they want our backing to extend there authority. If they have issues with Asian style teaching they should make it clear to the school owners rather than taking the same attitude as the gun raised police. They should work with the schools to develop the system they want rather than creating this duality in massage.
If you agree please write the CAMTC about these issues.
Lori Price said:
Daniel, Same here, I'm in Fountain Valley, and those places are like Starbucks, one on every corner. How do we make sure is following the law? Now that we have State permits, are the local PD even involved with MT any more?
Daniel Cohen said:Lori there are two within a half mile of my place but I am only 20 minutes from San Gabriel where you find 1 or 2 on every block. They are the one hour foot massage places. But for 10 extra dollars and often no extra charge you get a full body massage. Some places have 15 stations working. Because it was feet they use to get a beauty salon permit for estheticians then do full body. Some cities realized what it was and require massage permits. I don't mind if it is a level playing field but how do you compete if they skirt the regulations, get paid only tips (already ruled illegal in courts) and live 4 to a room. We should make sure that each place is following the law for at least reasonable competition.
MA doesn't even require a massage license for Asian Bodywork correct? I wonder what kind of business license they have. I have wondered how MA regulates this kind of thing when it is excluded from the massage law. Guess they just ignore it.
Tonya Brooks-Taylor said:
There are a host of such websites where seedy clients tell it all. I found this out a while ago when I was 'investigating' a business near me. There is this AMP less than two blocks away from my massage studio. When I first opened up my place was confused a few times with the MP and believe me I was not at all happy about it. I did some research online and in less than five minutes found several sites where the MP was listed by 'clientele' who discussed in detail the sexual services they received at the place! I anonymously shared the information with the state and local authorities but to date nothing has been done and it's been over two years. The MP is open all hours of the day and night (the Open sign never gets turned off! I've driven by at 1am and it's still on). I suspect authorities in town know what's going on but unfortunately no one seems to be bothered by it except for me :-(
© 2024 Created by ABMP. Powered by